John Carlson vs. Erik Karlsson

[Joker5123]

This may be a completely stupid comparison to you guys, but they're both great up and coming d-men.

NHL:
Karlsson had 60 games and 22 points in 2009-10, Drafted 15th, 2008.

Carlson had 20 games and 6 points in 2009-10, Drafted 27th, 2008.

AHL:
Karlsson had 12 games, and 11 points in 2009-10.

Carlson had 48 games, and 39 points in 2009-10.

Personally, Karlsson has my vote, he really seemed to get so much better, so much quicker at the end of the season, and the addition of Gonchar should boost his development.

[jpavs8cluthcy]

I love em' both, but I'll take Carl

[98monkeyboy98]

In 5 years Ottawas Defence will be the best in the league Karlsson Rundblad and Cowan

[redgibby]

For me it's Carlson no question...just my opinion though